The Meaning of Bankrupt

Every so often in the United States, I come across a discusion of the choice of the word "cramdown" (cram down, cram-down) to describe either stripping down liens or confirming a repayment plan without creditor consent. The basic thrust of these articles--the best of which is probably this treatment by William Safire--is that the word itself conveys a great deal about the cultural view of the legal action. In the context of cramdown, I think the word choice reflects the fact the U.S. legal regime generally protects the collection rights of secured creditors in bankruptcy.

At a recent World Bank event, a provocative discussion emerged on the choice of what to call people who file bankruptcy. The Working Group report notes an international trend in the law away from calling people "bankrupt" toward the term "debtor." Judge Wisit Wisitsora-at from Thailand offered a slightly different flavor on the problem--that whatever the word chosen, the literal translation, and cultural meaning, of of such a word can vary tremenedously. He reported that the current word in Thai for a person who files consumer bankrutpcy literally translated means "worse than a failure." Even a quick run of the word "bankrupt" through Google translate in several languages produces some words that are a far cry from the dominant U.S. perspective (at least among academics) of the Fragile Middle Class. Here's a sampling: beggar, penniless, upset, defeated, fallen down on the ground, and unsound.

Comments

[David]

I liked the proverb "fallen down on the ground". I had never thought such a word for bankruptcy.

[Ashlee]

Think I like the way Thai view it. It saddens me how may people in the us file for bankruptcy in the US and the attitude that we now have towards it. It is like that o.k. we know a lot of people who have had to file. Whats worse it is not that many of these people don't or can't make any money it is just that they do not know how to manage it and live beyond their means.

[Justin Robins]

Being in the real estate industry I see a lot of people claim bk. The sad part about it is that most of the people do it ever 5-7 years consistently. It's almost become a way of life for them. They will keep doing it as long as there are creditors willing to lend them money right out of bk.